Agenda item

Construct new detached masonry double garage

Temple Lake House, 53a Kimberley Road, Nuthall, Nottinghamshire, NG16 1DA

Constructnew detachedmasonrydoublegarage

TempleLakeHouse, 53aKimberleyRoad,Nuthall,Nottinghamshire,NG161DA

CouncillorJ MOwenhad askedthatthisapplicationbedeterminedby theCommittee.

There wereno lateitems fortheCommitteetotake noteof.

Mr PaulSingh, theapplicantand CouncillorJ MOwen, WardMember,maderepresentationsto theCommitteepriortothegeneraldebate.

The debate includedconsideration oftheproximityoftheproposed garagetothe neighbourand theadverseeffectof thegarageon thecharacterof thearea, which was considered contrary to theNuthallNeighbourhoodPlan. Therewas anacceptanceof theneedforthe garage,butit wasnotedthattherewerea numberof potentiallocationsthatwouldbe moreappropriate,as theywouldnot impactonneighbouramenity.

RESOLVED thatplanningpermission be refused, with the precise wordingof therefusalto bedelegatedto theChair ofthe PlanningCommittee and the Head ofNeighbourhoodsand Prosperity.

Reasons

1.          The proposeddevelopmentby virtueof itsscale andsitingclosetothewest boundaryofthesite willhavea detrimentalimpacton theneighbouringproperty atTheOldOrchard,7b EdwardRoad, resultingin anunacceptableloss of amenityfortheneighbouringproperty,contrary toPolicy H11of theBroxtoweLocalPlan (2004),Policy 10of theBroxtoweAlignedCore Strategyand Policy17of theDraftBroxtowePart2 LocalPlan(2018).

2.          The proposeddevelopmentwillbe outof keepingwith thecharacterof thearea, contrarytoPolicy H11of theBroxtoweLocalPlan (2004),Policy 10of theBroxtoweAlignedCoreStrategy,Policy 17of theDraftBroxtowePart2 LocalPlan (2018)andPolicy5 oftheNuthallNeighbourhoodPlan.