Agenda and minutes

Members are requested to declare the existence and nature of any disclosable pecuniary interest and/or other interest in any item on the agenda.

CouncillorG Marshalldeclareda non– pecuniaryinterestin item6.1as hispartner hadrecentlytakenout aleaseona commercialpropertyon ChilwellRoad.Minutenumber41.1 refers.

Councillor P DSimpsondeclareda non-pecuniary interestin item6.4 as hewas distantlyrelated toa neighbour.  Minutenumber 41.4refers.

The Committee is asked to confirm as a correct record the minutes of the meeting held on 5 December 2018.

Theminutesof themeetingon 5December2018wereconfirmedandsignedas a correctrecord.

The Committee received notifications of lobbying in respect of the planning applications subject to consideration at the meeting.

The Committee received notifications of lobbying in respect of the planning applications subject to consideration at the meeting.

The Head of Neighbourhoods and Prosperity will give the Committee a verbal update as to the progress of the Local Plan Part 2.

The Headof NeighbourhoodsandProsperityinformedthe meetingthatgoodprogresswas beingmadeon theLocalPlanPart 2.The Committeewas remindedthat whensites werenotdeliveredon previouslydevelopedsites,it couldleadtoan increasein developmentontheGreenBelt.

Construct 75 bed care facility; 30 supported living apartments (Class C2); bistro; gym/spa; hairdressers; bin, cycle and scooter stores; emergency generator; substation, car parking and landscaping

Myford Ltd, Wilmot Lane, Beeston

Construct75bedcarefacility;30 supportedlivingapartments(ClassC2);bistro;gym/spa;hairdressers; bin,cycle andscooter stores;emergencygenerator;substation,car parkingandlandscaping

MyfordLtd,WilmotLane,Beeston

The lateitemsforthisitem werenoted,includinganemailfroma residentneighbouringthe site,an amendmentto thenotes anda communicationfromBeeston andDistrictCivicSocietyrequestingthatnest bricksforswiftsbe included in thedesign.

Ms MargaretMetcalfe,objectingandCouncillorJ CPatrick,WardMember,addressedthe Committeepriortothegeneraldebate.

The Committeenotedthat theapplicanthadincludedtwoadditionalparkingspaces andhad identifieda pointof contactfor residents,as requested.Therewas a discussionabouttheimpacton lighttoneighbouringproperties.Itwas notedthatthe solarstudieshad beensubmittedwiththeapplicationandthese wereconsidered.

RESOLVEDthat planningpermissionbe grantedsubject tothe followingconditions:

1.      Thedevelopmentherebypermittedshall becommencedbefore the expirationof t  ...  view the full minutes text for item 41.1

Change of use of 28 flats (Class C3) to student accommodation (17 cluster flats) and construction of 3 cluster flats (providing 83 bed spaces in total)

Neville Sadler Court, Beeston, Nottinghamshire, NG9 2EW

Changeof useof 28flats(ClassC3)to studentaccommodation(17cluster flats)and constructionof3 clusterflats(providing83 bedspacesin total)

NevilleSadlerCourt,Beeston,Nottinghamshire,NG9 2EW

CouncillorP Lally hadrequestedthisapplicationbe determinedby PlanningCommittee.

Therewerelate itemspertainingto theapplicationwhichwereconsidered,includingacorrectiontothereportanda letterfroma neighbouroutliningtheir concerns.

CouncillorL ALally,WardMember,addressedthe Committeepriortothegeneraldebate.

The debatecoveredconcernsregardingthechangingcharacterof thepartsof BeestonneighbouringtheUniversity,theneed forthe LocalPlantoaddressstudentaccommodation,thesizeof thedevelopmentandthenumberof carparkingspaces thathad beenproposed.

Therefolloweda discussionabouttheneedfor starterhomesinBeeston.

It wasproposedby CouncillorP JOwenand secondedby CouncillorR IJacksonthat theitembedeferredto all  ...  view the full minutes text for item 41.2

Construct two dwellings

Land to the rear of 53 Kimberley Road, Nuthall, Nottinghamshire, NG16 1DA

Construct two dwellings

Land to The Rear of 53 Kimberley Road, Nuthall, Nottinghamshire, NG16 1DA

This application was withdrawn prior to the meeting.

Construct new detached masonry double garage

Temple Lake House, 53a Kimberley Road, Nuthall, Nottinghamshire, NG16 1DA

Constructnew detachedmasonrydoublegarage

TempleLakeHouse, 53aKimberleyRoad,Nuthall,Nottinghamshire,NG161DA

CouncillorJ MOwenhad askedthatthisapplicationbedeterminedby theCommittee.

There wereno lateitems fortheCommitteetotake noteof.

Mr PaulSingh, theapplicantand CouncillorJ MOwen, WardMember,maderepresentationsto theCommitteepriortothegeneraldebate.

The debate includedconsideration oftheproximityoftheproposed garagetothe neighbourand theadverseeffectof thegarageon thecharacterof thearea, which was considered contrary to theNuthallNeighbourhoodPlan. Therewas anacceptanceof theneedforthe garage,butit wasnotedthattherewerea numberof potentiallocationsthatwouldbe moreappropriate,as theywouldnot impactonneighbouramenity.

RESOLVED thatplanningpermission be refused, with the precise wordingof therefusalto bedelegatedto theChair ofthe PlanningCommittee and the Head ofNeighbourhoodsand Prosperity.

Reasons

1.          The proposeddevelopmentby virtueof itsscale andsitingclosetothewest boundaryofthesite willhavea detrimentalimpacton theneighbouringproperty atTheOldOrcha  ...  view the full minutes text for item 41.4

Change of use from shop (Class A1) to a ballet school (Class D2)

96 Derby Road, Stapleford, Nottinghamshire, NG9 7AD

Changeof usefromshop(ClassA1) toa balletschool(ClassD2)

96DerbyRoad,Stapleford,Nottinghamshire,NG9 7AD

CouncillorJ WMcGrathhadrequestedthat thisapplicationbedeterminedby PlanningCommittee.

TherewerenolateitemsfortheCommitteetotakeintoconsiderationwhen determiningthisdecision.

Ms GemmaHaigh,theapplicant andCouncillor JW McGrath,WardMember,made representationto theCommitteepriortothegeneraldebate.

Supportwasnoted forthe businessandit wasconsideredto bea positiveadditionto StaplefordTownCentre.Althoughconcernsabout parkingwerenoted, itwas alsonotedthat thepremiseshadplanningpermissionfora shop,whichcouldgeneratesimilarlevelsofparkingdemand.

RESOLVEDthat planningpermissionbe grantedsubject tothe followingconditions:

1.          Thedevelopmenthereby permittedshall becommenced beforetheexpirationof threeyearsbeginningwiththe dateofthepermission.

2.          Thedevelopmenthereby permittedshallbe carriedout inaccordancewith the SiteLocationPlan (1:1250)and ProposedBlockPlan(1:500)receivedby theLocalPlanningAuthorityon 16Octob  ...  view the full minutes text for item 41.5

Erect 10 one bedroom apartments

147 - 151 Queens Road, Beeston, Nottinghamshire, NG9 2FE

Erect10 onebedroomapartments

147- 151QueensRoad,Beeston,Nottinghamshire,NG92FE

CouncillorP Lally hadrequestedthisapplicationbe determinedby Planning Committee.

A numberof lateitemswerebroughttotheattentionof theCommitteefor considerationwith regardto thisitem,includingconfirmation from the Lead Local FloodAuthoritythattheyhadno objectionstothe scheme,alongsidethe requisitechangesto condition7 anda communicationoutliningconcernsfrom aneighbour.

Ms HeatherBlackwell,objectingandCouncillorL ALally, WardMember,addressedthe Committeepriortothegeneraldebate.

The debatefocusedon thenumberof flatsthat wereproposedforthe sizeof theplot beingoverintensive,thequalityof lifeforfutureoccupantsandthelack ofany carparkingspacesspecificallyfor thedevelopment.Therewas concernabouttheimpact onneighbouringpropertiesandthecharacterof thearea.

It wasproposedby CouncillorP JOwenand secondedby CouncillorR IJacksonthat theitembedeferredtoa futuremeetingto allowtimefortheappli  ...  view the full minutes text for item 41.6

The Committee is asked to NOTE that the position remains unchanged from that reported at its meeting on 22 March 2017.  The Council is not therefore currently at risk of special measures based on the figures reported to Committee on the aforementioned date.

The Committee noted that the position remained unchanged from that reported to it on 22 March 2017 and that the Council was not therefore at risk of special measures based on the figures reported to it on that date.

The Committee noted the decisions determined under delegated powers between 17 November 2018 to 21 December 2018.

Variations are proposed to the Section 106 Agreement which deviate from the decision taken by members of Planning Committee and therefore require the approval of the Members.

Variationstothe Section106 Agreementwereproposedwhichdeviatedfrom thedecisiontakenby membersof PlanningCommitteeandthereforerequiredthe approvalof theMembers.

Mr StevenMidgley,theapplicant,made representationto theCommitteepriortothe generaldebate.

The Committee is asked to RESOLVE that, under Section 100A of the Local Government Act, 1972, the public and press be excluded from the meeting for the following item of business on the grounds that it involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraphs 3 and 5 of Schedule 12A of the Act.

RESOLVED that, under Section 100A of the Local Government Act, 1972, the public and press be excluded from the meeting for the following item of business on the grounds that it involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as defined in paragraphs 3 and 5 of Schedule 12A of the Act.

RESOLVEDthatthesection106agreementbeamendedasfollows:

·            Removaloftheneedto undertakerepairworksto the tower prior to the practicalcompletionof10ormoredwellingswithinArea3, insteadproposingto undertakethe initialrepairworkswithintwoyearsand alltherepairworkswithinfive years.

·            Removal of theneedto fitoutfor conversionthe towerbuilding.